Municipal Surveillance Procurement Investigation

Technical Procurement Dossier: Transnational Cyber-Surveillance Integration via U. S. Municipal Policy Networks The integration of advanced, foreign-state-affiliated cyber-surveillance platforms into domestic United States municipal law enforcement agencies represents a highly coordinated, extra-legislative framework designed to bypass traditional legislative channels and standardize anti-bias enforcement at the local level. This commercial procurement pipeline, designated as" Vector 12, " links municipal policymaking to the acquisition of proprietary web-intelligence (OSINT), warrantless geolocation tracking, and predictive social-media monitoring tools. By coordinating directly with municipal executives, transnational advocacy groups embed surveillance priorities directly into local city halls, police departments, and school boards, establishing an efficient conduit for private-sector intelligence ingestion. The Transnational Policy-to-Procurement Conduit: The CAM Mayors Advisory Board and the Municipal Antisemitism Action Index The primary administrative engine driving local policy standardization and subsequent technical acquisition is the Mayors Advisory Board, launched in October 2025 by the Combat Antisemitism Movement (CAM). Chaired by Providence Mayor Brett Smiley, this board serves as the coordinating body for the regional implementation of CAM’s signature municipal policy blueprint: the Municipal Antisemitism Action Index. The geographic distribution of active municipal corridors implementing this index is highly concentrated across four strategic regional networks: ● The New England Flagship: Centered in Providence, Rhode Island, under Mayor Brett Smiley, which acts as the primary administrative testing ground and regional deployment engine for the Northeast. ● The South Florida Corridor: Managed through the Jewish Mayors and Municipal Leaders Association (JMMLA) and led by South Florida mayors, including Scott Singer (Boca Raton), Larisa Svechin (Sunny Isles Beach), Howard Weinberg (Aventura), Alix Desulme (North Miami), and Margaret Brown (Weston). This corridor has successfully integrated strict speech rules and commerce regulations. ● The Los Angeles Metro Corridor: Facilitated by Beverly Hills Mayor Sharona Nazarian and Riverside Mayor Patricia Lock Dawson, utilizing regional summits to deploy specialized campus policing standards and speech constraints. ● The Atlanta Metro Suburbs: Led by Sandy Springs Mayor Rusty Paul and Union City Mayor Vince Williams, who convene closed-door regional forums to inject the index's enforcement guidelines directly into public safety codes and school board administrative rules. During the January 2026 Georgia Mayors Roundtable on Antisemitism, hosted by Mayor Rusty Paul in Sandy Springs, nearly a dozen Atlanta-area mayors gathered alongside representatives from the Secure Community Network (SCN) and the Georgia Solidarity Network to codify these public safety metrics. Participating cities in these closed-door deliberations included Austell (Mayor Ollie Clemons), Duluth (Mayor Greg Whitlock), Dunwoody (Mayor Lynn Deutsch), Johns Creek (Mayor John Bradberry), Jonesboro (Mayor Donya Sartor), Palmetto (Mayor Theresa Thomas-Smith), and Roswell (Mayor Mary Robichaux), alongside delegations from Forest Park, Hampton, Mableton, McDonough, and Savannah. This regional activation demonstrates how symbolic commitments are rapidly translated into local administrative mandates. The adoption of the Municipal Antisemitism Action Index alters traditional municipal zoning, procurement, and policing codes. Under this framework, municipal procurement departments insert compliance clauses that disqualify commercial vendors who fail to sign pledges certifying they do not engage in boycotts of Israel or Israeli commerce. Crucially, the policy framework alters law enforcement operations by standardizing incident classification. Local police forces are instructed to classify non-violent political speech, protests, and anti-Zionist slogans as potential hate crimes or bias incidents. This administrative classification lowers the legal threshold for threat intelligence monitoring, establishing a direct policy-to-procurement trigger: the newly created administrative requirement to monitor" local bias threats" is used to justify the sole-source procurement of proprietary cyber-intelligence tools capable of mass data scraping and warrantless location tracking. Corporate Procurement and Contractor Tracing The commercial pipeline linking CAM-aligned jurisdictions to specialized cyber-intelligence firms relies on direct contract awards, budget amendments, and cooperative purchasing agreements. The primary entities facilitating this pipeline include Cobwebs Technologies (acquired by Spire Capital in 2023 and merged into PenLink, Ltd.) and Voyager Labs. The following table documents contract awards, municipal buyers, private vendors, and transaction values: Municipal / Agency Buyer Private Vendor / Contractor Technology Platform / Module Transaction Value Contract Term / Status Procurement Vehicle / Funding Source Washington, D. C. Homeland Security & Emergency Management Agency (HSEMA) Cobwebs Technologies (PenLink, Ltd.) Tangles (Web Intelligence Platform) $348,613.70 4-Year Licensing (2020–2024; $70k–$90k annually) Sole Source Purchase Order; District Fusion Center Allocation City of Panama City Beach, FL Cobwebs Technologies Tangles / Investigative Software Package $50,810.00 3-Year Initial Term (August 2023 – August 2026) RFP 23-41; Resolution No. 23-206; Budget Amendment #50 Queens County Cobwebs Technologies Tangles & WebLoc Value Undisclosed Annual Subscription Sole Source Procurement; Municipal / Agency Buyer Private Vendor / Contractor Technology Platform / Module Transaction Value Contract Term / Status Procurement Vehicle / Funding Source District Attorney, NY Integration (June 2, 2023 – June 1, 2024) PIN# QDA20230406 Los Angeles Police Department (LAPD) Voyager Labs Voyager Platform / Friendship Report Trial Deployment 4-Month Evaluation (2019) Discretionary Investigative Funding / Internal Trial U. S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) PenLink, Ltd. (Cobwebs Technologies) WebLoc (Location Tracking Product) Value Undisclosed No-Bid Contract Award (2025) Federal No-Bid Procurement Pipeline To bypass traditional competitive bidding laws and avoid public city council debate, municipal police departments routinely utilize master cooperative purchasing agreements. Carahsoft Technology Corporation acts as the premier" Master Aggregator" and distributor for Voyager Labs and associated cyber-surveillance platforms within the state and local municipal market. By leveraging pre-negotiated IT schedules—such as GSA Multiple Award Schedules (MAS), California Multiple Award Schedules (CMAS), and NASPO ValuePoint cooperative contracts—local agencies in CAM-aligned corridors can rapidly procure proprietary software licenses without triggering localized transparency requirements. Technical Infrastructure and Municipal Fusion Center Ingestion The technical integration of proprietary cyber-surveillance inputs into municipal policing databases and local Homeland Security Fusion Centers occurs through structured data pipelines. These systems ingest raw, unstructured data from the open, deep, and dark web, processing it through machine learning algorithms to output actionable intelligence, geofenced alerts, and network mapping. The data flow is powered by specific architectural components: Automated Semantic Tracking and Network Mapping The core system utilized for social media parsing is Cobwebs Technologies’ Tangles platform. An operator begins an investigation by inputting a single identifying seed—such as a phone number, email address, username, or photo. Tangles utilizes artificial intelligence to crawl the web, scrape unstructured social profiles, and automatically construct visual relation charts displaying mutual friends, frequent interactions, and indirect connections. Similarly, the Voyager Platform utilizes automated data scraping to analyze user connections, outputting a" Friendship Report" that maps direct and indirect social networks to identify hidden members of targeted associations. Warrantless Geolocation Tracking For spatial intelligence, agencies ingest data through Cobwebs' WebLoc module. WebLoc automatically monitors and analyzes real-time, commercial location data linked to mobile devices within specific geographic bounds. By integrating WebLoc feeds directly into local Fusion Centers (such as Washington, D. C. 's HSEMA), law enforcement operators establish continuous geofenced zones. The system is configured to trigger automated alerts when a targeted individual enters a preselected geographic range or posts from a specific location, allowing real-time tracking of protestors and assembly groups without a search warrant. Psychographic Sentiment and" Affinity" Profiling Voyager Labs’ software platforms analyze unstructured text and visual media to evaluate subjective criteria, such as the strength of a target’s ideological beliefs and their level of" passion". The system applies automated machine learning models to generate a color-coded risk score predicting the target’s" affinity for fundamentalism or extremism". These predictive risk scores and automated threat feeds are routed directly into municipal Real-Time Crime Centers (RTCCs) to drive preemptive policing allocations. The Dual-Track Private-Public Ingestion Loop Crucially, the technical stack is not limited to public municipal databases. Under the Municipal Antisemitism Action Index framework, localized" bias incident" and protest data gathered by municipal police are routed into state-level databases and CAM’s private registry, the Antisemitism Research Center (ARC). This database is further populated by AI-driven intake platforms, including Reportify —a generative AI application incubated by the Adir Challenge Foundation that formats raw campus incident reports into standardized civil rights complaints for automated routing into federal portals (civilrights. justice. gov). Additionally, CyberWell, an Israeli-linked big-data tracking engine, acts as a" trusted partner" to feed standardized semantic corpora directly into corporate social media moderation benches (such as Google Jigsaw's Perspective API and Meta's moderation systems), establishing a closed-loop pipeline where public police intelligence and private platform censorship operate in tandem. Grant Financial Architecture: Federal-Municipal Funding Channels The financial clearinghouse for these high-capital technical acquisitions relies on federal-to-local grant mechanisms administered by the Department of Homeland Security (DHS). Following the passage of the federal funding package signed on July 4, 2025, which appropriated $191 billion to DHS, state and local non-disaster grant funding was supercharged. Local police departments utilize these massive federal funding streams to purchase proprietary foreign-derived spyware with minimal public oversight. The primary funding conduits are: ● Urban Area Security Initiative (UASI): Focuses on high-density metropolitan areas and regional fusion centers, allowing municipal policing hubs to cover the high subscription costs of Cobwebs' Tangles and Voyager Analytics under the administrative category of" preventing domestic terrorism". ● Homeland Security Grant Program (HSGP): Provides broader funding to state and local agencies to enhance mobile and digital surveillance capabilities. Police departments justify these acquisitions by linking them to the security audits and threat assessments mandated by their adoption of the Municipal Antisemitism Action Index. ● Nonprofit Security Grant Program (NSGP): Leveraged by the CAM-aligned network to direct federal funding to local non-profit partners and private security committees, establishing localized private-sector surveillance nodes that feed data back to regional police databases. By routing the procurement of tools like Tangles, WebLoc, or Voyager Analytics through UASI and HSGP grants under the guise of" domestic hate-crime prevention" and" targeted threat mitigation, " municipal agencies bypass local general fund budget audits. This allows local police to acquire militarized cyber-intelligence platforms that would otherwise trigger intense public scrutiny and opposition from local taxpayers. The Transnational Funding Pipeline and FARA Evasion To execute these high-impact municipal advocacy and surveillance campaigns while evading the statutory disclosure requirements of the Foreign Agents Registration Act (FARA), the transnational network utilizes domestic U. S. 501(c)(3) non-profit organizations as financial cutouts. This FARA mitigation strategy was originally formulated within Israel's Ministry of Strategic Affairs under Brigadier General Sima Vaknin-Gil. By routing state funding through state-funded public-private partnerships—such as Kela Shlomo, later renamed Concert and currently operating as Voices of Israel—the network provides direct grant-making and management oversight to U. S. entities without leaving a direct paper trail that would trigger federal registration. The financial architecture supporting CAM and its municipal operations is detailed below: Primary Donor Entity Primary Recipient / Cutout Fiscal Year (FY) Transaction Value Operational Purpose & Channelling Flow Beren Sea Foundation (Adam E. Beren / Berexco LLC) Combat Hate Foundation (CAM Executive Hub) FY 2023 $3,592,222.00 General Operating Support; managed under Berexco CFO Donna Stucky Beren Sea Foundation (Adam E. Beren / Berexco LLC) Combat Hate Foundation (CAM Executive Hub) FY 2022 $3,125,000.00 General Operating Support; channelling corporate administrative control Beren Sea Foundation (Adam E. Beren / Combat Hate Foundation (CAM Executive Hub) FY 2024 $2,775,000.00 General Operating Support; underwriting Primary Donor Entity Primary Recipient / Cutout Fiscal Year (FY) Transaction Value Operational Purpose & Channelling Flow Berexco LLC) national municipal summits Beren Sea Foundation (Adam E. Beren / Berexco LLC) Combat Hate Foundation (CAM Executive Hub) FY 2020 $2,000,000.00 Seed Funding; Combat Hate Foundation incorporation in Moundridge, KS Beren Sea Foundation (Adam E. Beren / Berexco LLC) Combat Hate Foundation (CAM Executive Hub) FY 2021 $1,500,000.00 General Operating Support; administrative integration of Berexco staff Vine & Fig Tree Institute I Inc. (M. Michael Davis / Ari Gontownik) Vine & Fig Tree Fund Inc. FY 2025 $850,000.00 Inter-organizational grant-making to execute secondary downstream payouts Vine & Fig Tree Fund Inc. Combat Hate Foundation (CAM) FY 2024 $250,000.00 Targeted allocation supporting the Mayors Advisory Board launch Vine & Fig Tree Fund Inc. Philos Project FY 2024 $100,000.00 Downstream ideological alignment and community security advocacy Vine & Fig Tree Fund Inc. Merona Leadership Foundation (Adam Milstein) FY 2024 $100,000.00 Underwriting StopAntisemitism operations and Liora Rez's salary Israel Henry Beren Charitable Foundation Combat Hate Foundation FY 2024 $500,000.00 General support for local law enforcement security training initiatives Ric & Suzanne Kayne Foundation Combat Hate Foundation FY 2024 $500,000.00 Underwriting of regional South Florida Corridor JMMLA conventions Fidelity Investments Charitable Gift Fund Combat Hate Foundation FY 2020 $450,000.00 Donor-advised pass-through funding to preserve donor Primary Donor Entity Primary Recipient / Cutout Fiscal Year (FY) Transaction Value Operational Purpose & Channelling Flow anonymity Vanguard Charitable Combat Hate Foundation FY 2024 $305,000.00 Donor-advised funding for automated content filtering pilot programs Donor Advised Charitable Giving, Inc. Combat Hate Foundation FY 2022 $200,100.00 Core operating support for the development of online monitoring tools Combat Hate Foundation Network Contagion Research Institute (NCRI) FY 2022 $75,000.00 Outward grant to fund academic social media tracking and analysis Combat Hate Foundation Winning Strategies Washington FY 2020 $35,000.00 Outward payment for federal lobbying on municipal security policies Combat Hate Foundation International March of the Living FY 2022 $15,000.00 Cooperative educational funding and international delegate hosting The corporate leadership of the Combat Hate Foundation, located in Moundridge, Kansas, is directly intertwined with the executive team of Berexco LLC. Adam E. Beren, who founded CAM in 2019, concealed his leadership role until 2023, during which time the foundation was legally registered under Berexco CFO Donna Stucky and Berexco Corporate Executive Jonathan Oller, who continues to serve as treasurer. Day-to-day operations are administered by Executive Director Mikhail (Misha) Galperin, while global political coordination is managed by a governance board composed of high-ranking Israeli state actors, including former Deputy Prime Minister Natan Sharansky and former IDF Spokesperson Barney Breen-Portnoy. This leadership structure allows CAM to rapidly execute campaigns synchronized with the Israeli Ministry of Diaspora Affairs under a domestic philanthropic cover. Legal, Constitutional, and Civil Rights Risk Assessment The integration of privatized, foreign-state-affiliated cyber-surveillance systems into municipal policing through the CAM network creates severe civil rights, constitutional, and regulatory liabilities. These risks are exacerbated by the proprietary and opaque nature of the systems, which operate in a legal gray area free from the constitutional constraints imposed on public law enforcement agencies. Warrantless Surveillance and Fourth Amendment Evasion The deployment of modules like Cobwebs' WebLoc presents a severe threat to Fourth Amendment protections against warrantless searches. By purchasing commercially compiled cell phone location data and deep-web scraping feeds, municipal police departments systematically bypass the requirement to present probable cause of a crime to a neutral judge. The mass extraction of geolocation data from entire neighborhoods or political assemblies allows law enforcement to conduct warrantless dragnet tracking of citizens, regardless of their connection to criminal activity. This circumvention of judicial oversight has drawn severe congressional and legal scrutiny. First Amendment Chilling Effects and Platform Manipulation The reliance on platforms like Voyager Labs and Cobwebs fundamentally undermines First Amendment-protected activity, including free speech, assembly, and religious expression. Voyager Labs’ methodology relies on extracting personal data through platform manipulation. To scrape unstructured data, the company created over 38,000 fake user accounts to bypass privacy settings and extract information from over 600,000 Facebook users. This activity resulted in a major federal lawsuit by Meta in 2023 for term-of-service violations. Furthermore, because Voyager’s AI-driven algorithms score target risk based on cultural heritage, religious text references, and linguistic markers (such as Arab heritage or ordinary religious expressions), the technology systematically produces false positives, targeting marginalized populations and political dissenters for police surveillance. Extra-Legislative Policy Laundering and Foreign Influence The coordination between CAM, municipal executives, and private cyber-surveillance vendors represents a structured effort to bypass constitutional legislative channels. The Combat Antisemitism Movement is heavily financed by specialized domestic non-profit" cutouts"—including the Beren Sea Foundation (injecting over $13.1 million since 2020) and the Vine & Fig Tree Fund. These foundations act as financial buffers, isolating the operational entities from direct foreign funding streams to intentionally mitigate Foreign Agents Registration Act (FARA) registration requirements. The execution of this foreign-aligned advocacy is directed by former senior Israeli military, intelligence, and diplomatic officials integrated directly into CAM’s governance, such as Global Advisory Board Chair Natan Sharansky, former IDF Chief Censor Sima Vaknin-Gil, and former commander of the IDF Spokesperson’s Unit Sacha Roytman-Dratwa. Through this network, a foreign-aligned policy index (the Municipal Antisemitism Action Index) is integrated directly into municipal ordinances. Once adopted, it alters local law enforcement standards, redefining protected political speech as an actionable" bias threat". This broadened administrative definition then serves as the legal justification for the sole-source procurement of proprietary surveillance platforms. This represents an extra-legislative loop where private lobby groups dictate municipal policy, which subsequently triggers the acquisition of privatized, corporate spy tools to monitor and suppress domestic political dissent. Strategic Conclusions and Policy Safeguards The integration of foreign-state-affiliated cyber-surveillance systems into domestic U. S. municipal law enforcement via the Combat Antisemitism Movement's Mayors Advisory Board represents a critical intersection of policy laundering, federal grant diversion, and constitutional bypass. The adoption of the Municipal Antisemitism Action Index functions as an administrative tool, systematically lowering the legal and operational thresholds for municipal police departments to acquire and deploy invasive web-intelligence and warrantless location-tracking systems. Supported by massive DHS grant programs, local agencies are quietly integrating proprietary, algorithmically biased technologies that violate fundamental First and Fourth Amendment protections. To counter the systemic proliferation of privatized, unaccountable intelligence networks within domestic law enforcement, the following technical and policy safeguards are recommended: ● Mandatory Municipal Procurement Audits: Establish rigorous local and federal auditing protocols for municipal procurement of dual-use cyber-surveillance systems, specifically targeting cooperative purchasing schedules (such as Carahsoft) and state-level IT schedules to ensure all software acquisitions undergo public bidding and municipal council reviews. ● Prohibition of Warrantless Geofenced Tracking: Enact strict municipal and state-level ordinances banning the ingestion, licensing, and utilization of location intelligence and geofenced device-tracking modules (such as WebLoc) by municipal law enforcement and local fusion centers without a specific, judicially approved warrant based on probable cause. ● Enforce Independent Algorithmic Audits: Mandate that any predictive policing or sentiment analysis platform (such as Voyager Analytics) undergo independent, third-party technical audits to identify and eliminate algorithmic bias, specifically prohibiting the utilization of subjective" passion" or" ideological affinity" scoring metrics. ● Establish Non-Profit Conflict-of-Interest Disclosures: Require municipal executives and members of Mayors Advisory Boards to file formal public disclosures regarding any policy frameworks, travel, lodging, or operational funding received from private non-profit entities (such as CAM) prior to voting on or adopting policy indices that trigger subsequently aligned technology procurements. ● Enforce FARA Compliance Investigations: Direct the Department of Justice to launch comprehensive investigations into transnational advocacy networks utilizing domestic 501(c)(3) foundations as financial cutouts to execute foreign-aligned policy and technology agendas while evading Foreign Agents Registration Act (FARA) mandates. ● Protect Public Data Ingest Pipelines: Restrict the routing of domestic law enforcement" bias incident" and protest tracking data to private, third-party databases (such as CAM's ARC), ensuring that public safety telemetry remains strictly subject to public records laws, judicial review, and constitutional protections. Works cited 1. North Miami Mayor Appointed to National Board to Fight Antisemitism, https://www. northmiamifl. gov/CivicAlerts. aspx? AID=442 2. Mayors Form New Multi-City Board to Fight Antisemitism, https://combatantisemitism. org/press-release/mayors-form-new-multi-city-board-to-fight-antisemi tism/ 3. Atlanta-Area Mayors Convene for Antisemitism Forum, https://www. atlantajewishtimes. com/atlanta-area-mayors-convene-for-antisemitism-forum/ 4. Texas Police Invested Millions in a Shadowy Phone-Tracking Software. They Won't Say How They've Used It., https://www. texasobserver. org/texas-police-invest-tangles-sheriff-surveillance/ 5. 1 Via Public FOIA Portal August 7, 2025 Joe Ruel FOIA Officer District of Columbia Homeland Security and Emergency Management Ag - ACLU of DC, https://www. acludc. org/app/uploads/2025/08/8.5.2025-FOIA-Request-Cobwebs. pdf 6. Voyager Labs Government IT Procurement Contracts - Carahsoft, https://www. carahsoft. com/voyager-labs/contracts 7. Intelligent Investigation Solutions for Law Enforcement - Voyager Labs, https://www. voyager-labs. com/solutions/law-enforcement/ 8. Voyager Labs — $101M Raised — Reviews & Alternatives | StartupHub. ai, https://www. startuphub. ai/startups/voyager-labs 9. Meta Sues Surveillance Firm That Worked with Police | Brennan Center for Justice, https://www. brennancenter. org/our-work/analysis-opinion/meta-sues-surveillance-firm-worked-p olice 10. Cobwebs Technologies Web Intelligence Investigation Platform RENEWAL SUBSCRIPTION - The City Record Online (CROL) | Notice Details, https://a856-cityrecord. nyc. gov/RequestDetail/20230406118 11. LAPD Documents Show What One Social Media Surveillance Firm Promises Police, https://www. brennancenter. org/our-work/analysis-opinion/lapd-documents-show-what-one-social -media-surveillance-firm-promises 12. DHS-built surveillance apparatus to surge in year ahead, documents show | FedScoop, https://fedscoop. com/dhs-surveillance-technology-ai-funding-document-spyware/ 13. Brown Leads Oversight Letter to DHS on ICE's Troubling Mass Surveillance Tech, https://shontelbrown. house. gov/media/press-releases/brown-leads-oversight-letter-dhs-ices-trou bling-mass-surveillance-tech 14. Rep. Garamendi, Espaillat and 70 Democrats Call for Investigation of ICE, DHS Warrantless Purchases of Americans' Location Data, https://garamendi. house. gov/media/press-releases/rep-garamendi-espaillat-and-70-democrats-c all-investigation-ice-dhs